Selecting an Embedded Board Designer

Selecting an Embedded Board Designer

It is quite typical for companies to outsource their embedded design and other electronic and board design needs to other firms. Sometimes companies have innovative ideas they want to bring to market but not the internal electronics expertise, sometimes larger firms don't have the internal capacity or don't do enough electronics or embedded design to justify the dedicated staff.

Own Your Design

There are two major business models that embedded design firms use. Some firms make their money by selling you the boards and have a very low or non-existing up-front engineering fee. If you don't have a need to reduce your per-unit cost and don't expect to make changes to your design in the future, this may be an option. However, they usually require you to buy a minimum number of boards to recoup engineering costs and make a good profit.

Other firms charge you engineering fees for board and software design and allow you to shop out the fabrication to anyone. Often these firms allow you to own the source code for the board design and software they develop for your system. While up-front engineering costs are greater, you can significantly reduce your per-unit costs and have the peace of mind that comes with knowing you aren't beholden to your design firm for future hardware and software updates.

Documentation Matters

With product design, it can often be very helpful to have a solid documentation of your product design and rationale behind the design. It may be well over a decade before changes are made to your design, and it will be difficult to remember why that capacitor was put in, or why that resistor value was chosen. You do not want to risk recreating issues that were solved long ago. For this reason, it may be a good idea to work with a firm that has experience documenting designs and uses source control to track design changes.

Know Your Needs and Their Capabilities

With microprocessors and micro-controllers in just about anything you might touch (vehicles, buildings, appliances, phones, toys), embedded and electronics design has become a very broad field. Understand the needs of your design and make certain you select a design firm with appropriate expertise. Things to consider include:

  • Communication networks
  • Power consumption (mobile, etc.)
  • Durability and environmental concerns
  • Overall complexity
  • Other circuit design needs (motor drivers, audio amplification, signal conditioning, etc.)

More Than Just Circuits

In our interconnected world, It's very common for the capabilities of embedded devices to go beyond the device itself. Often times devices can interface with networks, central services, peripheral devices, databases, etc., through WiFi, Ethernet, phone lines, USB, Bluetooth, ZigBee, etc. The reasons for doing so could include remote automated firmware updates, data collection for failure analysis or client support, parameter setup, etc.

Depending upon your needs, it may make sense to hire a firm with a track record of developing solutions for the systems your device will interface with, for example web based applications, server based applications, or database applications.

Bringing an Old Design to a New Firm

For whatever reason, sometimes the original designer is no longer an option for future system updates, in which case it is common for a client to bring their design to a new firm. There are a couple things to keep in mind should you find yourself in this situation. While most firms have a preferred design environments, just because they don't use the environment your board was designed in doesn't mean they cannot support you. Most of the bigger name packages these days, such as Altium Designer have sophisticated import tools. Make sure to keep your original source files for the board layout and software, because this will save the firm a significant amount of development time. Any documentation you have may also be a big help.

Does an embedded system even make sense?

Lastly, it may be a good idea to consider a firm that doesn't just do embedded designs. A company that has expertise with a wide variety of off-the-shelf control system hardware may be able to help you decide if there is a quicker and less costly alternative to developing a custom embedded solution. In some cases this may allow you to get a product to market more quickly and with less risk. In a future blog post, I will go over some guidelines for choosing between an embedded solution and one that used off-the-shelf hardware. Stay tuned, and in the mean time, check out our Embedded Design page to learn more about DMC's capabilities.


There are currently no comments, be the first to post one.

Post a comment

Name (required)

Email (required)

Enter the code shown above:

Related Blog Posts